|Year : 2023 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 258-269
Potential of essential oils as alternative permeation enhancers for transdermal delivery
Jayshree Mahanty1, Sofi Haamid Rasheed1, Sudhir Kumar1, Harjeet Singh2, Alok Sharma1
1 Department of Pharmacognosy, ISF College of Pharmacy, Moga, Punjab, India
2 CCRAS, Ministry of AYUSH, Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh, India
|Date of Submission||26-Apr-2021|
|Date of Acceptance||04-Nov-2021|
|Date of Web Publication||21-Jul-2022|
Dr. Alok Sharma
Department of Pharmacognosy, ISF College of Pharmacy, Moga - 142 001, Punjab
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Transdermal drug delivery plays a significant part in the drug delivery system when compared to other routes of drug administration. The function of the stratum corneum (SC) is a barrier. Recently, numerous methods have been thrived to improve the perforation of drugs across the skin. The most effective method is to use enhancers since these agents enhance skin permeability. Natural penetration enhancers like essential oils demonstrate higher enhancement activity and are more widely accepted than synthetic penetration enhancers. High potential in the expansion and interaction with the SC intercellular lipids has led to an increasing interest in these oils as penetration enhancers. This article gives an overview of a few essential oils, including their mode of action and important parameters for permeation improvement. The present work can provide essential oils as alternative enhancers, and this could be useful in transdermal administration.
Keywords: Essential oil, natural permeation enhancers, skin, stratum corneum, transdermal drug delivery
|How to cite this article:|
Mahanty J, Rasheed SH, Kumar S, Singh H, Sharma A. Potential of essential oils as alternative permeation enhancers for transdermal delivery. World J Tradit Chin Med 2023;9:258-69
|How to cite this URL:|
Mahanty J, Rasheed SH, Kumar S, Singh H, Sharma A. Potential of essential oils as alternative permeation enhancers for transdermal delivery. World J Tradit Chin Med [serial online] 2023 [cited 2023 Sep 25];9:258-69. Available from: https://www.wjtcm.net/text.asp?2023/9/3/258/351508
| Introduction|| |
Among other routes of drug administration, the transdermal route plays a critical role as a means to deliver drugs. By evading hepatic first-pass metabolism, this drug prolongs its effects. The DDS has a disadvantage in that SC has a barrier function, and in order to overcome this drawback, skin permeation enhancers are used. A formulation's permeability enhancement is determined by the degree to which it effectively increases the permeability of the skin, mucosa, or a test membrane, and permeation enhancers are the agents that provisionally decrease the skin impermeability. In general, there are three main types of permeation enhancers: physical, synthetic, and natural. The skin's uppermost layer is called the epidermis.
The epidermis is a layer of stratified squamous epithelium that acts as a physical, chemical, and biological barrier. Stratum corneum (SC) is localized on the outermost layer of the epidermis and has two major structural components: coenocytes and inter-corneocyte lipid. Thus, SC, a layer of lethally differentiated cornified cells in the topmost epidermis, forms, which is responsible for the skin's barrier attributes. Keratinocytes provide essential lipid components for skin function during epidermal differentiation. Nevertheless, lipid composition changes substantially from the basal layer to the SC when the keratinocytes pass through the SC. As a result of these changes, phospholipids and glycosphingolipids are exhausted, resulting in an increase in ceramides, cholesterol, free fatty acids, and small amounts of cholesterol sulfates and cholesterol esters. The epidermal permeability barrier influences several cutaneous activities, including epidermal proliferation, differentiation, lipid synthesis, cytokine expression, and innate immunity.
The barrier qualities of transdermal drug administration must be tailored to allow adequate drug absorption to attain effective levels at an appropriate location. The most commonly used method for modifying SC properties has been the use of permeation promoters in the transdermal drug delivery (TDD) system. As compared with conventional synthetic permeation enhancers, natural permeation enhancers (NPEs) provide better permeation and reduced skin irritation. Transdermal application of various essential oils exhibiting alternative permeation enhancer abilities is illustrated in the graphic abstract. So far, there has not been a comprehensive review on the permeation effects of essential oils on SC. A literature review was done to look at achievements in the chemistry, transdermal utilization, and pharmacology of essential oils. Moreover, the present review will provide information about essential oils, their bioactive constituents, and interactions with TDD.
| Skin Anatomy|| |
A significant organ in the body, the skin, is composed of many layers that protect the internal parts of the body from the external environment. The epidermis is a stratified, squamous, keratinizing epithelium which is the uppermost layer of skin and constitutes around 90% keratinocytes, which is liable for the barrier properties of the skin, however, the physical properties, shape, and size of keratinocytes alter during migration to the skin surface., The dermis consists primarily of connective tissue and faces the epidermis as a physical barrier for larger molecules. The dermis and epidermis adjoin at a junction, known as the dermal-epidermal junction. The hypodermis is an adipose tissue layer that connects the dermis, aponeurosis, and fasciae of the muscles.
| Permeation Enhancers|| |
By decreasing the skin's impermeability, permeation enhancers facilitate the drug absorption across the skin. Enhancing permeation through the interaction of permeation enhancers and polar head groups of lipids is ideal. Due to altered interactions between the lipid–lipid head linker and the wrapping arrangement of the lipids, hydrophilic drugs diffuse more readily. Permeation enhancer increases the content of water molecules within the bilayer, increasing cross-sectional area for polar drug diffusion.
Ideal properties of permeation enhancers
It is important that permeation enhancers be pharmacologically inert, well suited to drugs and excipients, odorless, economical, and have appropriate solvent properties. The ideal permeation enhancers must not deplete body fluids or electrolytes, and the skin must instantly regain its barrier properties. Permeation enhancers must be nonallergic, nonirritating, and nontoxic. Enhancers should allow therapeutic agents to enter the body. Permeation enhancers should be physically and chemically stable, and they should be compatible with formulation and ingredients and must have a reproducible duration of action. A single permeation enhancer alone cannot exhibit all the essential features.
Routes of permeation
A drug can cross the skin barrier via different routes, as demonstrated by Hueber et al. [Figure 1] represents the transepidermal route of drug penetration through the intact skin. A molecule can penetrate the normal intact human skin via the appendageal and transepidermal routes. The appendageal pathway, also known as the shunting route, involves transporting ions and big polar molecules through sweat glands, hair follicles, and their associated sebaceous glands, which is favorable for ions and large polar molecules that rarely travel through the SC. Despite having the highest permeability, these pathways are of marginal significance because they cover only 0.1% of the entire skin area.
|Figure 1: The transepidermal route of drug penetration through the intact skin involves the path of molecules via the stratum corneum, an architecturally diverse multilayered and cellular barrier. The intra-cellular path allows the transport of hydrophilic solutes. Whereas, transport via inter-cellular spaces allows diffusion of lipophilic solutes via continuous lipid matrix|
Click here to view
Types of permeation enhancers
Permeation enhancers can be classified as physical, chemical, and natural.
Physical permeation enhancers
By using ultrasonic, magnetic, and physical separation, physical permeation enhancers increase penetration. In order to improve the permeation capability of drugs, multiple methods such as iontophoresis, electroporation, ultrasound, microneedles, and radiofrequency are used. Physical permeation enhancers must be nonallergic and nonirritating in order to be effective, allowing therapeutic compounds to enter the body while avoiding a deficit of biological material in the body. The use of physical permeation enhancers is widely used in pharmaceutical applications to improve the transport of drug molecules. As an example, electroporation is primarily used to initiate DNA into a cell body. Hepatocellular carcinomas (≤3 cm) are commonly treated with radiofrequency ablation.
Chemical penetration enhancers
Chemical permeation enhancers are distinguished by their pharmacological inertness, nonallergen, rapid onset of action, and optimum duration of action, as well as their economic and cosmetic acceptability. Chemical penetration enhancers (CPEs) bind directly to hydrophobic lipid tails and alter their packaging to facilitate fluidity and enhance drug penetration.
A CPE possesses numerous advantages, such as an appropriate rate of permeation for therapeutic efficacy. Transdermal surface formulations were improved in terms of permeation. The CPEs may also be disadvantageous, in that the concentration of distinct drugs is not the same, so the same dosage cannot be used. It is not recommended to use certain permeation enhancers together at different concentrations. In most cases, chemical permeation enhancers are ineffective for medical applications due to their toxicity.
Natural permeation enhancers
These natural penetration enhancers contain mainly glycerides, which are formed from fatty acids and glycerin. Unlike animal fats, most plant-mediated oils are liquid at a specific temperature and contain low concentrations of saturated fats and elevated amounts of unsaturated and monounsaturated fats. Coconut oil is an exception, as it is semi-solid at room temperature and has a high saturated fat content. There are many different kinds of oils, each with its own set of qualities. As shown in [Figure 2], NPEs are classified into terpenes, volatiles, and fixed oils. Monounsaturated, unsaturated, and saturated fatty acids can all be found in plant-based oils. Furthermore, distinct oils have characteristic fatty acid constituents with altering chains of varying lengths and degrees of saturation. Furthermore, some essential oils are unstable, prone to degradation and oxidation, as well as breakdown and microbe growth. Hence, the distinguishing features of distinct oils emphasize the significance of judicious choice for skin moisturization.
|Figure 2: Potential natural permeation enhancers: Natural permeation enhancers are new classes of permeation enhancers which include essential oils and may support in enhancing the drug permeation into the stratum corneum. It may be classified into three types of essential oils such as terpenes, volatile oil, and fixed oil|
Click here to view
| Selected Essential Oils as Natural Permeation Enhancers|| |
Essential oils or aromatic oils might be considered natural alternatives to chemical enhancers as they include a diverse range of bioactive components. The prevalent compounds such as terpenes and terpenoids are illustrated in [Figure 3]. Besides, [Table 1] also demonstrates a view of the percentage of bioactives in NPEs and their allied applications. Further, [Table 2] summarizes the details about the skin penetration enhancement effect of NPEs.
|Figure 3: Essential oils as natural permeation enhancers: The main constituents are terpenes, terpenoids, etc. Essential oils exhibit varied and applicable as natural permeation enhancers|
Click here to view
|Table 1: Percentage of bioactives in natural permeation enhancers and their allied applications|
Click here to view
|Table 2: Skin penetration enhancement effect of natural permeation enhancers|
Click here to view
Basil oil is extracted from the leaves of Ocimum basilicum, a member of the Lamiaceae family. Methyl chavicol (40%–80%), linalool (5%–10%), 1,8-cineole (1%–7%) and eugenol (1%–10%), ursolic acid (1%–2.5%), and oleanolic acid (0.15%–0.17%) are the chemical constituents present in basil., Ursolic and oleanolic acids play a role in skin permeation enhancement. A rise in keratinocyte differentiation and lipid production is induced by ursolic and oleanolic acids. Basil oil is beneficial for enhancing immune function, protecting against infection, and reducing water retention. Fang et al. studied the effect of basil oil extract on drug penetration through the dorsal skin of Wistar rats using Franz diffusion cells. Both in vitro and in vivo studies were conducted to determine the degree of drug uptake within the skin reservoir. Basil essential oils were evaluated for low and high polarity. Estragole, squalene (triterpene), and sesquiterpene, α-bergamotene, and θ-muurolene make up the low polarity part. Other than estragole, which is oxygenated, the other components were hydrocarbons. Phytol (aliphatic diterpene) was the major compound of the high-polarity portion, others being oxygenated terpenes, including d-linalool, estragole, and butylated hydroxytoluene. Leu et al. discovered that both the proportions improved the skin penetration of indomethacin, however, low-polarity portion improved the permeation more efficiently. Jain et al. found that a preliminary treatment with basil oil improved the skin penetration and absorption of indomethacin. Basil oil acts by enhancing drug absorption across the SC and causing alterations in the skin's physiology. Based on in vivo microdialysis, the low-polarity group had higher subcutaneous indomethacin levels than the standard group, whereas the high-polarity group had negligible indomethacin concentrations. As compared to lipophilic indomethacin, basil essential oil showed lower enhancing activity than hydrophilic 5-fluorouracil (5-FU). The differences between the in vitro and in vivo epidermal deposition experiments appeared to indicate that the high-polarity part was better able to hold the drug inside the skin as compared to the lower polarity portion.
According to Jain et al., basil oil was proven to be more efficient than camphor, geraniol, thymol, or clove oil in enhancing the permeation of aqueous labetalol hydrochloride through rat lower abdominal skin. The ursolic, oleanolic acid along with the solvent system (ethanol-water, 60:40) showed a synergistic effect with complete fluctuating quantities. By forming viable H-bonds among ceramides and terpenes in phytoconstituents, the rigid connections of phospholipid bilayers are loosened, allowing structural permeation to occur. Bioactives with the most electronegative alcoholic class, such as basil oil, react with peptide groups of ceramides, in contrast to bioactives with less electronegative carboxylic groups and their derivatives, such as camphor, which contains a ketone oxygen atom. As compared to camphor, geraniol exhibited a minimum enhancement ratio, even though these essential oils contained more electro donating alcoholic oxygen atoms. According to this study, the physicochemical characteristics of the permeant molecules, as well as those of the enhancer molecules, influence the penetration of a molecule through the peritoneal skin.
The ripe fruits of Elettaria cardamomum (Zingiberaceae) are used to extract cardamom oil. It comprises various chemical constituents, namely α-terpineol (45%–55%), myrcene 27%, limonene 8%, menthone 6%, β-phellandrene 3%, 1,8-cineol 2%, sabinene 2%, and heptane 2%. α-terpineol is the main bioactive constituent of cardamom oil. The packing of hydrophobic lipids in the stratum corneum is disrupted as a result. In addition, cardamom oil has been used to treat toothaches and muscular discomfort as an antibacterial and pain reliever. An acetone extraction of cardamom seeds was examined by Yamahara et al., to determine if it affected skin penetration of prednisolone. Acetyl terpineol and terpineol were isolated from acetone extract and fractionated. In comparison with Azone (1-dodecyclazacycloheptan-2-one), the two components, along with further separated compounds, show that prednisolone enhances skin permeation.
According to Williams et al, in vitro, cardamom oil improved the penetration of indomethacin, diclofenac, and piroxicam through abdominal rabbit skin. The skin permeation index was computed using the flux of the enhancer-containing preparation and the flux of the standard preparation without the enhancer. Huang et al., discovered that piroxicam at pH 5.8 and pH 7.4 with 1% cardamom oil had the greatest enhancing effect when compared to indomethacin and diclofenac. At a concentration of 1% cardamom oil, reduced lag times were observed for indomethacin and diclofenac penetration through the epidermis. The findings suggest that, rather than drug solubility in a solvent system, cardamom oil's stimulating action is influenced by its concentration, pH, and physicochemical properties. Huang et al., found that pretreating rabbit abdomen skin for 30 min with 5% cardamom oil in alcohol: water solvent mixture (1:1) increased the peak area of the piroxicam plasma concentration time curve (area under the curve: 0–24) by 67.09 times when compared to nontreated skin. The total bioavailability was found to be 83.23%. Permeation was comparable after 60 min pretreatment and 30 min pretreatment.
Chamomile oil is extracted from the flowers of Matricaria chamomilla L., a member of the Asteraceae family. The chemical constituents present in chamomile oil are chamazulene (6.46%), α-bisabolone oxide A (35.74%), (Z)-β-farnesene (6.63%), α-bisabolol oxide A (19.07%), and apigenin (1%–2%). Apigenin is a significant bioactive which enhances skin permeability, keratinocyte differentiation, lipid production, and lamellar body. The oil can also be used for wound healing, including ulcers and sores, anxiety relief, and sleep promotion. Hu et al., evaluated mouse skin permeation after pretreatment with apigenin. The husky appearance of mice's skin did not change after 9 days of topical apigenin therapy. In comparison to vehicle-treated mice, apigenin did not change the transepidermal water loss (TEWL) rates or standard skin surface pH. When compared to vehicle-treated mice, apigenin-treated mice demonstrated little but negligible SC hydration. Variation in baseline TEWL and topical apigenin sped up barrier recovery, which was especially noticeable 4 h after severe barrier disruption. Based on these findings, topical apigenin significantly enhanced epidermal penetration barrier homeostasis in healthy mouse skin.
Citronella oil is isolated from the leaves of the Cymbopogon nardus plant, which belongs to the Gramineae family. It consists of numerous constituents, such as citronellal (32%–45%), geranyl acetate (3%–8%), geraniol (11%–13%), and limonene (1%–4%). Geraniol is responsible for the enhancement of epidermal permeability. Geraniol disrupts the hydrophobic lipid packing of the SC. Citronella oil is also used therapeutically to get rid of parasites and worms from the digestive tract, as well as for increasing appetite and reducing fluid retention.
The first time citronella was demonstrated to enhance permeation across the abdominal skin of a male Wistar rat by Arellano et al., The outcomes revealed that geraniol, a bioactive present in citronella oil, was shown to be an effective accelerant for diclofenac sodium. In comparison to nerolidol (14-fold increase) and menthol, geraniol demonstrated a 20-fold increase in skin permeability (11-fold increase). Geraniol has the best increasing effect of all alcohols. Structures with hydrocarbon tails and polar heads disrupt the lipid packaging of the SC layer. In general, terpenes bearing molecules were better at absorbing hydrophilic medicines through the skin, whereas hydrocarbon terpenes were better at absorbing lipophilic drugs via the skin. Drug absorption through the skin is critically affected by the geraniol, physiochemical nature of drugs, as well as the vehicle in preparations. Geraniol is an efficient skin permeation enhancer out of eleven monoterpenes comprising (+)-limonene, (−)-menthone, (+)-terpinen-4-ol, α-terpineol, 1,8-cineole, (+)-carvone, (−)-verbenone, (−)-fenchone, p-cymene, (+)-neomenthol, and geraniol examined to enhance the caffeine penetration across the hairless mouse skin., Hydrocortisone and triamcinolone acetonide are other replica drugs with differing lipophilicities. Essential oils were administered in propylene glycol at 0.4 M about 1 h before the application of drugs. The pretreatment signifies that SC penetration of caffeine was increased. After removing the enhancement influence of propylene glycol on caffeine penetration, geraniol shows an enhancement ratio of 1.76 (15.7 before removing), followed by neomenthol with a 1.52-fold rise (13.6-fold before removing).
There are about seven hundred species of Eucalyptus in the family Myrtaceae. The eucalyptus oil contains various chemical constituents such as eucalyptol (60%–85%), α-pinene (10%–20%), (+)-limonene (1%–10%), and 4-methylcumene (1%–5%). A main bioactive of eucalyptus oil is 1,8-cineole or eucalyptol, which is liable for the enhancement of skin permeability. It is a colorless cyclic ether and monoterpenoid liquid. It increases the fluidity of SC lipids and has a spicy aroma and taste. As a result, it's used in flavourings, colognes, and cosmetics. In addition, it is also utilized in numerous brands of mouthwash and cough suppressants. Rajan & Vasudevan investigated the use of essential oils to improve skin penetration of the polar drug 5 FU. Using excised human skin, they examined 5 FU's penetration enhancing activity. In this study, the drug permeability coefficient was enhanced by 30 times when eucalyptus oil was used using eucalyptus oil as an enhancer. Moreover, eucalyptus oil works less effectively as a permeation enhancer compared with 1,8-cineole, a main component in eucalyptus. This may be acceptable because the bioactives present in plant essential oils are not at their maximal thermodynamic activity. Furthermore, several essential oils contain bioactives that, through a variety of physiochemical approaches, can restrict transdermal delivery. Karpanen et al. in their study revealed that the main constituent i.e., eucalyptol (1,8-cineole), present in eucalyptus oil improved the permeation effect of drugs, chlorhexidine (2%(w/w) within the dermal and epidermal bottom layer. Researchers found that the mixture of chlorhexidine, isopropyl alcohol (70%), and eucalyptus oil (10%) enhanced the drug permeability within the dermis 2 min after application, in comparison to either chlorhexidine or isopropyl alcohol alone.
The dried ripe fruit of the Foeniculum vulgare Mill, which belongs to the Umbelliferae family, is used to extract essential fennel oil. The bioactives present in fennel oil are (60%–80%) anethole, (12%–16%) fenchone, (3%–5%) α-pinene, and (2%–5%) estragole. Fennel oil is largely composed of anethole, which is a chemical compound that increases skin permeability. It penetrated the SC and broke down the hydrogen bonds. Fennel oil is also used for treating various digestive problems, such as heartburn, gas, and loss of appetite. In a study, fennel oil was discovered to be an efficient skin permeation enhancer. Das et al. reported that pretreatment of fennel oil with propylene glycol increased the penetration of trazodone hydrochloride; however, pretreatment by fennel oil (10%) in propylene glycol indicated the improvement ratio of 9.25 as compared to the standard. The presence of phytochemicals with variable physicochemical properties and molecular weights (MWs) in different essential oils could be the cause of differences in penetration enhancement ratios. Low boiling degrees and MWs of trans-anethole and 1,8-cineole may contribute to fennel oil's maximal enhancement ratio.
Peppermint oil contains menthol, a noteworthy bioactive that plays a key role in enhancing epidermal permeability. Through altering the intercellular packing, it increases skin dissemination and alters the lipid structure. Peppermint oil also has therapeutic effects on digestion, oral hygiene, stress reduction, pain relief, and blood circulation. It is isolated from the leaves of Mentha piperita belonging to the family Lamiaceae. The bioactives present in peppermint oil are menthol (9%–48%), l-menthone (13%–20%), Menthofuran (4.56%-18.2%), 1,8-cineole (2%–5%), pulegone (2%–5%), and methyl ethanoate (4%–10%). In vitro penetration research was performed for evaluating the activity of peppermint oil on the human breast; Nielsen used various concentrations 0.1%–5% (v/v) in aqueous solutions comprising 1% (v/v) Tween, 0.9% (w/v) sodium chloride, and distilled water (H2O). The fluidity of H2O indicates the skin's durability, and a higher flux value indicates impaired skin. The results of this investigation showed that at higher concentrations of oil, H2O flux also increases. However, at lower concentrations, a reduction in H2O permeation was observed, suggesting that the SC has a defensive effect. Peppermint oil was found to have significant effects on skin barrier function, and as a result, it was investigated beyond to predict its action on benzoic acid SC at various concentrations. A finding revealed that peppermint oil was defensive at levels of 0.1% and 1.0% (v/v) against the permeation of hydrophilic drugs.
Olive oil (OO) is extracted from the fruits of Olea europaea. It comprises oleic acid (75%–85%), accompanied by minor amounts of fatty acids including linoleic acid (21%) and palmitic acid (20%). OO has around 200 unique chemical components, such as sterols, triterpenes, alcohols, and phenolic components. Antioxidants of OO are richer in hydrophilic phenols. The antioxidant effects of phenolics are greater than those of Vitamin E. It was reported by Cooke et al. that 52% of newborn nurseries support OO skin therapy. Danby et al. examined the effects of OO and sunflower oil (SFO) for skin barrier in two groups of adult people with or without the etiology of atopic dermatitis (AD). Group 1 comprised six adults with AD, topically administered OO to arm twice a day for at least 5 weeks, whereas another arm was used as a control. The TEWL was 2.3 times higher in Group 1 when olive oil was used to cure both hands instead of control (P = 0.001). And the OO-healed hands had SCs that have been 23% slimmer as compared to control forearms. Whereas Group 2 comprised six adults with a record of AD and other groups (6 adults) without any record of AD, and topically administered OO to one arm and sunflower oil to the alternative arm bis a day for four 28 days. These results from murine animal studies revealed that OO increased skin permeability.
Epidermis barrier function does not develop until a few weeks after the baby is born, hence skin maintenance is needed to assist early neonates' undeveloped skin barrier. An Austrian organization investigated the efficacy of water-based lanolin cream (Bepanthen) versus oil-based lanolin cream (OO cream) or no emollient using arbitrary infants as subjects. Skin dehydration and irritation were measured by using a four-point scale. The water- and oil-based cream group had both significantly reduced flaking and scaling dermatitis in the fourth week, compared to the group that did not achieve soothing. Oil-based cream was more effective than Bepanthen cream in curing dermatitis at weeks 2, 3, and 4. A study by Kiechl-Kohlendorfer et al. showed that OO may be beneficial to the skin of newborns.
Orange peel oil
Orange peel oil is extracted from orange peel. It contains carvone, menthol, and hesperidin. Hesperidin is a major component in orange peel oil. Hesperidin enhances epidermal permeability, keratinocyte differentiation, lipid production, and lamellar body. The medicinal properties of orange peel include lowering blood pressure, improving heart health, and lowering bad cholesterol. In vivo studies of the activity of hesperidin were performed on normal murine skin. Hou et al. first evaluated the mouse skin permeability after pretreatment with hesperidin. The husky appearance of mice did not change after topical application of 2% hesperidin two times daily for at least 6 days. The TEWL, the surface pH, or the SC hydration did not change between the hesperidin- and vehicle-treated groups. The barrier recovery was significantly improved in mice treated with hesperidin at both 2 h and 4 h following severe barrier disturbance with monotonous tape stripping (retrieval rates at 2 h, 11.21 ± 4.64 for vehicle treated and 48.54 ± 4.56 for hesperidin treated, P < 0.0001; at 4 h, 37.41 ± 5.17 for vehicle treated and 60.90 ± 4.58 for hesperidin treated, P < 0.005. N = 12 for all). Thus, hesperidin topical application increased epidermal permeability in mice with normal skin.
By distilling oleoresin from Pinus longifolia Roxb belonging to the family Pinaceae, turpentine oil was isolated. The bioactives present in turpentine oil are α-pinene (75%–85%), β-pinene (~3%), and camphene (4%–15%), and limonene (di pentene 5%–15%)., Charoo et al. demonstrated that when turpentine oil was combined with a cosolvent of isopropyl and alcohol-propylene glycol, flurbiprofen was permeated more readily in SC. Turpentine oil exhibits the greatest infiltration capacity at a concentration of 5%(v/v) and is more efficient than tulsi at the same concentration. SC layer interruption is the primary reason for this. Turpentine oil was employed to penetrate matrix transdermal patches containing diclofenac diethylamine and to improve flow in ketoconazole transdermal films. The transdermal films made up of ketoconazole distributed curative conditions of the drug in a stable and long-term manner. It acts as a permeation enhancer to improve the permeability of ketoconazole. According to the findings, as the concentration of turpentine oil rises, drug permeability increases as well. It contains essential oils that show a synergistic effect, and it also enhances the permeability of the drug due to the rise in interruption of the SC.
| Effect of Natural Permeation Enhancers|| |
Increased TDD of water-soluble drugs can be a consequence of the miscibility and solubility characteristics of enhancers. Leaching of epidermal lipids is the mechanism by which NPEs promote the permeation of oil-soluble drugs. It is important to improve partitioning properties at the SC tissue interface to enhance the permeation of lipophilic compounds. By combining both permeation enhancers and cosolvents, this can be accomplished. Few enhancers tend to cause keratin to swell and remove SC's structural material. Thus, decreasing diffusional resistance and increasing permeability of lipophilic compounds. [Figure 4] briefly highlights the mechanics of NPEs, indicating that they are responsible for interrupting the highly structured lipid arrangement within corneocytes in the SC. Furthermore, they interact with proteins' intercellular regions, altering their conformational state and making SC more drug permeable. Further, [Table 3] compares chemical and NPEs. In addition, modern cosmetics and biological tools are used to investigate and validate the functions of essential oils in SC. The bioactive components of essential oils that increase drug permeability in SC are listed in [Table 4], along with their chemical structures and mechanisms of action.
|Figure 4: Natural permeation enhancers transport the drugs through the skin by various mechanisms of action: (a) Interruption of the highly ordered intercellular lipid structure among the corneocytes in the stratum corneum, (b) interaction with intercellular domain of protein, which stimulates their conformational alterations and makes stratum corneum more permeable for drugs, (c) partitioning promotion – many solvents alter the features of the stratum corneum|
Click here to view
|Table 3: Comparison between chemical penetration enhancers and natural permeation enhancers|
Click here to view
|Table 4: Bioactives of selected essential oils with their structures and mechanism of action|
Click here to view
| Safety of Essential Oils as Permeation Enhancers|| |
Biochemical configuration and concentration determine to a large extent the toxicity of Essential oils EO s and their bioactives. Accordingly, noxious and appropriate reports receive a precise response on their safety and use of enhancers for drug penetration. EOs and their bioactive components are quickly absorbed into the bloodstream through the skin and eliminated from the body via urine and feces. Lan et al. revealed key elements present in the essential oils of lavender (linalyl acetate and linalool); cypress oil from aroma bath exhibited increasing transdermal absorption after 10–20 min bathing of mice. The transdermal absorption of limonene from grapefruit oil was detected in mice's blood and brain after 20 min of bathing. It was found that lavender oil's bioactives permeate into the skin of male mice after massaging it for 20 min, and their highest concentration is found in the blood after that time. While major constituents were eliminated from the bloodstream 90 min after the massage. Studies have shown that after topical application of the EOs, the bioactives and their metabolites are continuously metabolized, not accumulated. In this case, EOs were quickly eliminated from the culture, demonstrating their potential as a permeation enhancer.
| Components Influencing the Permeation Enhancing Capability|| |
Lipophilicity of the drug
The physicochemical features of drugs, such as lipophilicity, MW, and melting point, are inextricably linked to their penetration into the skin. The recommended logP for a drug to infiltrate the SC is 1–3, with a maximum MW limit of 500. The proposed QSAR model for assessing the drug's skin penetrability is log kp = 6.3 + 0.71 logP0.061 MW, where Kp is the skin penetrability coefficient. Drug lipophilicity is a prevalent factor influencing skin penetrability. A parabolic relation was discovered among logP values of drugs and the ratio of enhancement of NPEs. ER = 4.89 (logP) 2 + 12.34 logP + 25.87, r = 0.682, showing that limonene can achieve the best drug penetration impact. The same results were observed in borneol. When 1% borneol was present, the values were represented by the model ER = 0.46 (logP) 2 + 0.41 logP + 5.18 (r = 0.86); when 3% borneol was present, the values were described by the model ER = 1.57 (logP) 2 + 2.64 logP + 13.58 (r = 0.79). By improving the function of hydrophilic drugs, borneol may achieve optimal penetration. By plotting camphor ER against drug logP values, a parabolic curve emerges. The result describes that hydrophilic drugs are more likely to be detected by NPEs than hydrophobic ones.
Lipophilicity of the natural permeation enhancer
NPEs have lipophilicity that makes it easier to estimate their permeation enhancement effects. NPE phytoconstituents like limonene provide permeation enhancement for lipophilic drugs, whereas a polar group in menthol, 1,8-cineole, enables permeation enhancement for hydrophilic drugs., NPEs with higher logP values were shown to be the most effective for lipophilic drugs as they were easier to combine with SC lipid bilayers and enhanced the reliability of SC's barrier function, allowing for drug skin penetration. The penetration of lipophilic valsartan, menthone, was enhanced most by anethole, one of the phytoconstituents of NPE tested. The less efficient permeation enhancer was eugenol. However, it was noticed that the highest lipophilicity of NPE resulted in the lower partitioning of ondansetron into the SC.
The concentration of the natural permeation enhancer
NPEs at a concentration of 0.4%–5% were employed in the TDD system. An increase in NPE concentration usually enhances the permeation enhancement effect. A rise in the drug's ER values with increased NPE concentration might be ascribed to NPE's capacity to improve skin barrier characteristics, but a decrease in drug permeation at high NPE concentration could be due to the drug's interaction with NPE.
| Conclusion|| |
Transdermal drug administration has a number of advantages over oral drug administration, prompting researchers to look at ways to get beyond the skin's barrier function by employing essential oils as NPEs. In recent years, the demand for TDD has been continuously increasing, inspiring numerous researchers to deliver drugs through the skin. It may be unsafe and ineffective to use chemical enhancers with the SC as their action is confined to the upper layers. Chemical enhancers increase drug penetration through the skin with an increase in skin irritation as chemical enhancer concentration is increased in formulation. As a consequence, it is tough to strike the right balance between chemical enhancer safety and effectiveness. Owing to their natural origin, good penetration capacities, few adverse effects, and inexpensive cost, essential oils are good penetration enhancers for TDD systems. Several oils have been shown to enhance the penetration of hydrophilic and lipophilic drugs through the epidermis, and these oils could be employed as safe permeation enhancers to increase transdermal absorption of drugs from topical formulations. To facilitate the commercial manufacturing of future transdermal products that are efficient, more research is required to expand NPEs. Therefore, the absorption of drugs across the skin may be enhanced by essential oils.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Mathias NR, Hussain MA. Non-invasive systemic drug delivery: Developability considerations for alternate routes of administration. J Pharm Sci 2010;99:1-20.
Anselmo AC, Mitragotri S. An overview of clinical and commercial impact of drug delivery systems. J Control Release 2014;190:15-28.
Pereira R, Silva SG, Pinheiro M, Reis S, Vale ML. Current status of amino acid-based permeation enhancers in transdermal drug delivery. Membranes (Basel) 2021;11:343.
Elias PM. Stratum corneum defensive functions: An integrated view. J Gen Intern Med 2005;20:183-200.
Lim SW, Hong SP, Jeong SW, Kim B, Bak H, Ryoo HC, et al.
Simultaneous effect of ursolic acid and oleanolic acid on epidermal permeability barrier function and epidermal keratinocyte differentiation via peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-alpha. J Dermatol 2007;34:625-34.
Deniz AA, Abdik EA, Abdik H, Aydın S, Şahin F, Taşlı PN. Zooming in across the skin: A macro-to-molecular panorama. Adv Exp Med Biol 2020;1247:157-200.
Sawada E, Yoshida N, Sugiura A, Imokawa G. Th1 cytokines accentuate but Th2 cytokines attenuate ceramide production in the stratum corneum of human epidermal equivalents: An implication for the disrupted barrier mechanism in atopic dermatitis. J Dermatol Sci 2012;68:25-35.
Hu LZ, Man HB, Peter M. Elias, Man MQ. Herbal medicines that benefit epidermal permeability barrier function. Dermatologica Sinica 2015; 33: 90-5.
Alkilani AZ, McCrudden MT, Donnelly RF. Transdermal drug delivery: Innovative pharmaceutical developments based on disruption of the barrier properties of the stratum corneum. Pharmaceutics 2015;7:438-70.
Haque T, Talukder MM. Chemical enhancer: A simplistic way to modulate barrier function of the stratum corneum. Adv Pharm Bull 2018;8:169-79.
Kala S, Juyal D. Recent developments on natural transdermal penetration enhancers. Int J Pharm Sci Res 2018;9:2190-6.
Yousef H, Alhajj M, Sharma S. Anatomy, Skin (Integument), Epidermis.(Updated 2019 Jun 12). statPearls [(Internet). Treasure Island (FL): statPearls Publishing (2019).
Kolarsick PA, Kolarsick MA, Goodwin C. Anatomy and physiology of the skin. J Dermatol Nurses Assoc 2011;3:203-13.
Hsu YC, Li L, Fuchs E. Emerging interactions between skin stem cells and their niches. Nat Med 2014;20:847-56.
Ng KW, Lau WM. Skin deep: The basics of human skin structure and drug penetration. In: Percutaneous Penetration Enhancers Chemical Methods in Penetration Enhancement. Berlin, Heidelberg. Springer; 2015. p. 3-11.
Venus M, Waterman J, McNab I. Basic physiology of the skin. Surgery (Oxford) 2010;28:469-72.
Liu Y, Liang F, Zheng HF, Zhao LG, Ge XY, He ZG. Development and in vitro evaluation of a topical use patch containing diclofenac diethanolamine salt. Asian J. Pharmaceut. Sci 2007;2:106-113.
Sivasankarapillai VS, Das SS, Sabir F, Sundaramahalingam MA, Colmenares JC, Prasannakumar S, et al
. Progress in natural polymer engineered biomaterials for transdermal drug delivery systems. Materials Today Chemistry 2021;19: 100382.
Maher S, Geoghegan C, Brayden DJ. Intestinal permeation enhancers to improve oral bioavailability of macromolecules: Reasons for low efficacy in humans. Expert Opin Drug Deliv 2021;18:273-300.
Ranade VV. Drug delivery systems. 6. Transdermal drug delivery. J Clin Pharmacol 1991;31:401-18.
Hueber F, Wepierre J, Schaefer H. Role of transepidermal and transfollicular routes in percutaneous absorption of hydrocortisone and testosterone: In vivo
study in the hairless rat. Skin Pharmacol 1992;5:99-107.
Ali S, Shabbir M, Shahid N. The structure of skin and transdermal drug delivery system – A review. Res J Pharm Technol 2015;8:103-9.
Barry BW. Drug delivery routes in skin: A novel approach. Adv Drug Deliv Rev 2002;54 Suppl 1:S31-40.
Roy N, Agrawal M, Chaudhary S, Tirkey V, Dhwaj A, Mishra N. Review article on permeation enhancers: a major breakthrough in drug delivery technology. International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research 2017;8: 1001.
Rodríguez Cruz I, Doínguez-Delgado C, Escobar-Chávez J., López-Cervantes M, Díaz-Torres R. Physical penetration enhancers: an overview. Current Technologies to Increase the Transdermal Delivery of Drugs; Bentham Science Publishers: Sharjah, United Arab Emirates 2016;2: 3-34.
Mathur V, Satrawala Y, Rajput MS. Physical and chemical penetration enhancers in transdermal drug delivery system. Asian Journal of Pharmaceutics (AJP) 4, no. 3 (2010).
Dragicevic N, Atkinson JP, Maibach HI. Chemical penetration enhancers: Classification and mode of action. In: Percutaneous Penetration Enhancers Chemical Methods in Penetration Enhancement. Berlin, Heidelberg. Springer; 2015. p. 11-27.
Ghadiri M, Young PM, Traini DJ. Strategies to enhance drug absorption via nasal and pulmonary routes. Pharmaceutics 2019;11:113.
Aungst BJ. Absorption enhancers: Applications and advances. AAPS J 2012;14:10-8.
Beardsell D, Francis J, Ridley D, Robards K. Health promoting constituents in plant derived edible oils. Journal of Food Lipids 2002;9: 1-34.
Tamarkin D. Foam: A unique delivery vehicle for topically applied formulations. In: Handbook of Formulating Dermal Applications: A Definitive Practical Guide. New York, USA: Wiley Online Library; 2016. p. 233-60.
Nordin MA. Effects of Brucea javanica and Piper betle extracts on oral Candida SPP/Mohd-Al-Faisal Nordin. PhD diss., University of Malaya, 2012.
Sharma R, Rao R, Kumar S, Mahant S, Khatkar S. Therapeutic potential of citronella essential oil: A review. Curr Drug Discov Technol 2019;16:330-9.
Fang JY, Leu YL, Hwang TL, Cheng HC. Essential oils from sweet basil (Ocimum basilicum
) as novel enhancers to accelerate transdermal drug delivery. Biol Pharm Bull 2004;27:1819-25.
Stewart D. The chemistry of essential oils made simple: God's love manifest in molecules. Marble Hill, Mo: Care publications; 2005.
Fox, LT., Minja G, Jeanetta DP, Josias H. H. Transdermal drug delivery enhancement by compounds of natural origin. Molecules 2011;16: 10507-10540.
Patel S. Plant essential oils and allied volatile fractions as multifunctional additives in meat and fish-based food products: A review. Food Addit Contam Part A Chem Anal Control Expo Risk Assess 2015;32:1049-64.
Jain R, Aqil M, Ahad A, Ali A, Khar RK. Basil oil is a promising skin penetration enhancer for transdermal delivery of labetolol hydrochloride. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2008;34:384-9.
Ashokkumar K, Murugan M, Dhanya MK, Warkentin TD. Botany, traditional uses, phytochemistry and biological activities of cardamom [Elettaria cardamomum
(L.) Maton] – A critical review. J Ethnopharmacol 2020;246:112244.
Yamahara J, Kashiwa H, Kishi K, Fujimura H. Dermal penetration enhancement by crude drugs: In vitro
skin permeation of prednisolone enhanced by active constituents in cardamon seed. Chem Pharm Bull (Tokyo) 1989;37:855-6.
Huang YB, Wu PC, Ko HM, Tsai YH. Cardamom oil as a skin permeation enhancer for indomethacin, piroxicam and diclofenac. International journal of pharmaceutics 1995; 126: 111-117.
Huang YB, Wu PC, Ko HM, Tsai YH. Effect of pretreatment by cardamom oil on in vivo percutaneous absorption of piroxicam gel: Pharmacokinetic analysis in rabbits. International journal of pharmaceutics 1996;134: 183-191.
Wany A, Shivesh J, Vinod KN, Dev MP. Chemical analysis and therapeutic uses of citronella oil from Cymbopogon winterianus: A short review. International Journal of Advanced Research 2013;6: 504-521.
Berkers T, Visscher D, Gooris GS, Bouwstra JA. Degree of skin barrier disruption affects lipid organization in regenerated stratum corneum. Acta Derm Venereol 2018;98:421-7.
Arellano, A., Santoyo S., Martin C., Ygartua P. Enhancing effect of terpenes on the in vitro percutaneous absorption of diclofenac sodium. International journal of pharmaceutics 1996;130: 141-145.
Godwin DA, Michniak BB. Influence of drug lipophilicity on terpenes as transdermal penetration enhancers. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 1999;25:905-15.
Mura S, Manconi M, Fadda AM, Sala MC, Perricci J, Pini E, et al.
Penetration enhancer-containing vesicles (PEVs) as carriers for cutaneous delivery of minoxidil: In vitro
evaluation of drug permeation by infrared spectroscopy. Pharm Dev Technol 2013;18:1339-45.
Luís Â, Andreia D, Jorge G, Fernanda D, Ana PD. Chemical composition, antioxidant, antibacterial and anti-quorum sensing activities of Eucalyptus globulus and Eucalyptus radiata essential oils. Industrial Crops and Products 2016;79: 274-282.
Vecchio, Gabriella M, Loganes C, Minto C. Beneficial and healthy properties of Eucalyptus plants: A great potential use. The Open Agriculture Journal 2016;10:52-7.
Rajan R, Vasudevan DT. Effect of permeation enhancers on the penetration mechanism of transfersomal gel of ketoconazole. J Adv Pharm Technol Res 2012;3:112-6.
] [Full text]
Gupta SK, Kumar S. Transdermal drug delivery enhancement by essential oils of Eucalyptus globules
. Adv Biol Res 2014;8:249-50.
Karpanen TJ, Conway BR, Worthington T, Hilton AC, Elliott TS, Lambert PA. Enhanced chlorhexidine skin penetration with eucalyptus oil. BMC Infect Dis 2010;10:278.
Saharkhiz MJ, Tarakeme A. Essential oil content and composition of fennel (Foeniculum vulgare
L.) fruits at different stages of development. J Essent Oil Bear Plants 2011;14:605-9.
Herman A, Herman AP. Essential oils and their constituents as skin penetration enhancer for transdermal drug delivery: A review. J Pharm Pharmacol 2015;67:473-85.
Das MK, Bhattacharya A, Ghosal SK. Effect of different terpene-containing essential oils on percutaneous absorption of trazodone hydrochloride through mouse epidermis. Drug Deliv 2006;13:425-31.
Vikas S, Seema S, Gurpreet S, Rana AC, Baibhav J. Penetration enhancers: A novel strategy for enhancing transdermal drug delivery. Int Res J Pharm 2011;2:32-6.
Balakrishnan A. Therapeutic uses of peppermint – A review. J Pharm Sci Res 2015;7:474.
Beigi M, Torki-Harchegani M, Ghasemi Pirbalouti A. Quantity and chemical composition of essential oil of peppermint (Mentha×piperita
L.) leaves under different drying methods. Int J Food Properties 2018;21:267-76.
Nielsen JB. Natural oils affect the human skin integrity and the percutaneous penetration of benzoic acid dose-dependently. Basic Clin Pharmacol Toxicol 2006;98:575-81.
Inglese P, Famiani F, Galvano F, Servili M, Esposto S, Urbani S. 3 factors affecting extra-virgin olive oil composition. Horticultural reviews 2011;38:83.
Cooke A, Michael JC, Simon D, Tina L. Use of oil for baby skincare: A survey of UK maternity and neonatal units. British Journal of Midwifery 2011;19:354-62.
Danby SG, AlEnezi T, Sultan A, Lavender T, Chittock J, Brown K, et al.
Effect of olive and sunflower seed oil on the adult skin barrier: Implications for neonatal skin care. Pediatr Dermatol 2013;30:42-50.
Darmstadt GL, Mao-Qiang M, Chi E, Saha SK, Ziboh VA, Black RE, et al.
Impact of topical oils on the skin barrier: Possible implications for neonatal health in developing countries. Acta Paediatr 2002;91:546-54.
Kiechl-Kohlendorfer U, Berger C, Inzinger R. The effect of daily treatment with an olive oil/lanolin emollient on skin integrity in preterm infants: A randomized controlled trial. Pediatr Dermatol 2008;25:174-8.
Man MQ, Yang B, Elias PM. Benefits of hesperidin for cutaneous functions. Evid Based Complement Altern Med 2019;2019:2676307.
Hou M, Man M, Man W, Zhu W, Hupe M, Park K, et al.
Topical hesperidin improves epidermal permeability barrier function and epidermal differentiation in normal murine skin. Exp Dermatol 2012;21:337-40.
Mercier B, Prost J, Prost M. The essential oil of turpentine and its major volatile fraction (α-and β-pinenes): A review. Int J Occup Med Environ Health 2009;22:331-42.
Charoo NA, Shamsher AA, Kohli K, Pillai K, Rahman Z. Improvement in bioavailability of transdermally applied flurbiprofen using tulsi (Ocimum sanctum
) and turpentine oil. Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces 2008;65:300-7.
Wang FL, Ji HM, Zhu JY, Xu GJ, Guan YZ, Chen YJ. Penetration enhancement effect of turpentine oil on transdermal film of ketorolac. Tropical Journal of Pharmaceutical Research 2015;14: 1341-1348.
Nokhodchi A, Sharabiani K, Rashidi MR, Ghafourian T. The effect of terpene concentrations on the skin penetration of diclofenac sodium. Int J Pharm 2007;335:97-105.
Lin TK, Zhong L, Santiago JL. Anti-inflammatory and skin barrier repair effects of topical application of some plant oils. Int J Mol Sci 2018;19:70.
Viljoen JM, Cowley A, du Preez J, Gerber M, du Plessis J. Penetration enhancing effects of selected natural oils utilized in topical dosage forms. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2015;41:2045-54.
Lahora D, Chaudhary V, Shah SK, Swami G, Chaudhary G, Saraf SA.Terpenes: Natural skin penetration enhancers in transdermal drug delivery system. Int J Pharma Res Dev 2011;2: 39-45.
Inoue S, Ishihara H, Uchida K, Yamaguchi H. Preferential percutaneous absorption of monoterpene hydrocarbons and ester of essential oils in mice placed in aroma bath and alteration of compositions of essential oils. Aroma Research 2000;1:75-83.
Lan Y, Wu Q, Mao YQ, Wang Q, An J, Chen YY, et al.
Cytotoxicity and enhancement activity of essential oil from Zanthoxylum bungeanum
Maxim. as a natural transdermal penetration enhancer. J Zhejiang Univ Sci B 2014;15:153-64.
Lan Y, Wang JY, Liu Y, Ru QG, Wang YF, Yu JX, et al.
Effect of terpene penetration enhancer and its mechanisms on membrane fluidity and potential of HaCaT keratinocytes. Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi 2015;40:643-8.
Bartosova L, Bajgar J. Transdermal drug delivery in vitro
using diffusion cells. Curr Med Chem 2012;19:4671-7.
Lan Y, Li H, Chen YY, Zhang YW, Liu N, Zhang Q, et al.
Essential oil from Zanthoxylum bungeanum
Maxim. and its main components used as transdermal penetration enhancers: A comparative study. J Zhejiang Univ Sci B 2014;15:940-52.
Yi QF, Yan J, Tang SY, Huang H, Kang LY. Effect of borneol on the transdermal permeation of drugs with differing lipophilicity and molecular organization of stratum corneum lipids. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2016;42:1086-93.
Xie F, Chai JK, Hu Q, Yu YH, Ma L, Liu LY, et al.
Transdermal permeation of drugs with differing lipophilicity: Effect of penetration enhancer camphor. Int J Pharm 2016;507:90-101.
Yang Z, Teng Y, Wang H, Hou H. Enhancement of skin permeation of bufalin by limonene via reservoir type transdermal patch: Formulation design and biopharmaceutical evaluation. Int J Pharm 2013;447:231-40.
Williams AC, Barry BW. Penetration enhancers. Adv Drug Deliv Rev 2012;64:128-37.
Zhou W, He S, Yang Y, Jian D, Chen X, Ding J. Formulation, characterization and clinical evaluation of propranolol hydrochloride gel for transdermal treatment of superficial infantile hemangioma. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2015;41:1109-19.
Can AS, Erdal MS, Güngör S, Özsoy Y. Optimization and characterization of chitosan films for transdermal delivery of ondansetron. Molecules 2013;18:5455-71.
Black K. Magnifeco: Your Head-to-Toe Guide to Ethical Fashion and Non-Toxic Beauty. Gabriola Island: New Society Publishers; 2015.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]