• Users Online: 263
  • Print this page
  • Email this page

Table of Contents
Year : 2015  |  Volume : 1  |  Issue : 1  |  Page : 5-15

The role of the European Pharmacopoeia (Ph Eur) in quality control of traditional Chinese herbal medicine in European member states

1 Sino-Dutch Centre for Preventive and Personalised Medicine/SU BioMedicine, Utrechtseweg 48, 3700AJ Zeist, the Netherlands
2 University of Regensburg Department of Pharmacy, Universitätsstraße 31, 93040 Regensburg, Germany

Date of Web Publication11-Sep-2020

Correspondence Address:
Gerhard Franz
University of Regensburg Department of Pharmacy, Universitätsstraße 31, 93040 Regensburg
Mei Wang
Sino-Dutch Centre for Preventive and Personalised Medicine/SU BioMedicine, Utrechtseweg 48, 3700AJ Zeist
the Netherlands
Login to access the Email id

Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None

DOI: 10.15806/j.issn.2311-8571.2014.0021

Rights and Permissions

In order to assure the safety and efficacy of the Chinese Medicines in Europe, the quality of TCM herbals should be guaranteed so that they can be freely imported in the European Union and other Western European Countries which are signatories of the European Pharmacopoeia Convention. Consequently, new Ph Eur TCM herbal drug Monographs should be elaborated, based on preexisting Monographs in the Chinese Pharmacopoeia (ChP) 2010.
Such a program has been inaugurated in 2005 by the Ph Eur Groups of Experts 13 A and B (Phytochemistry). Since then good progress has been made, elaborating of about one third of the originally proposed 100 TCM herbals being identified as important monographs for the European Market. Taking into account the many challenges still laying ahead, the establishment of a specialized Working Party (WP) on TCM with specialists and experts from many EU Member States has been decided by the Ph Eur Commission in 2008 which is highly active ever since in the examination and elaboration of new TCM herbal drug monographs, primarily to assure the safety of the European patient and further to provide quality parameters extremely important for all registration and licensing procedures of the respective National Authorities all over Europe.
This paper is a survey of results and difficulties obtained so far which has been encountered meanwhile in the elaboration process by the Ph Eur TCM WP of these monographs and will discuss these in detail. Moreover the role of Ph Eur TCM monographs in the European community is addressed.

Keywords: European Pharmacopeia (Ph Eur), Chinese Pharmacopoeia (ChP), Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), TCM monographs, herbal drugs and quality control

How to cite this article:
Wang M, Franz G. The role of the European Pharmacopoeia (Ph Eur) in quality control of traditional Chinese herbal medicine in European member states. World J Tradit Chin Med 2015;1:5-15

How to cite this URL:
Wang M, Franz G. The role of the European Pharmacopoeia (Ph Eur) in quality control of traditional Chinese herbal medicine in European member states. World J Tradit Chin Med [serial online] 2015 [cited 2023 Dec 1];1:5-15. Available from: https://www.wjtcm.net/text.asp?2015/1/1/5/294848

  Introduction Top

Since ancient times, all cultures have developed health care strategies, which are often characterized by a holistic approach to living organisms. A holistic approach to living organisms has been the basis of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) from its earliest years[1],[2]. The TCM approach is recognizing the uniqueness of each human being and the necessity to develop a personalized medication to obtain optimal results based on multi-component treatments[3]. Because of this specific feature, TCM becomes more and more popular in treatment and prevention of diseases in other cultures. In the past two decades public interest in herbal therapies (Phytomedicine) has increased significantly in Europe. Traditional Chinese herbal medicines including Chinese crude herbal materials and manufactured herbal products are a frequently used form of traditional medicines. Currently, the practice of TCM is not only popular in China and some Asian regions; but also it is appreciated worldwide. A large-scale study of the Chinese population of Taiwan showed that from 1996 to 2001, more than 60% of all subjects have used Chinese medicine during a 6-year interval. TCMs (85.9%) were the most common modality[4]. It was estimated that more than 1.5 billion people all over the world are trusting in the efficacy and safety of Chinese medicine[5]. In the ‘Western World’, the term ‘alternative’ medicine is now often replaced by ‘complementary’ medicine. This emphasizes the complimentary nature of TCM and Western medical systems. The latest term ‘integrative’ medicine underpins the gain that can be obtained when Western and complementary modalities are used together[3]. Data provided by the Chinese Import and Export Chamber of Commerce of Medicine and Health Products shows yearly export sales of traditional Chinese herbal medicinal products to the EU of approximately 12 million US dollars over the last four years suggesting a significant amount of TCM products entering EU market. In respect to this, quality control should be one of the important aspects to guarantee the safe use of TCM products for the patient.

The European Directorate for the Quality of Medicines (EDQM) is an organization which belongs to the Council of Europe (head quarter in Strasbourg, France) which is a leading organization that protects public health by:

  • enabling the development,
  • supporting the implementation, and
  • monitoring the application of quality standards for safe medicines and their safe use. Their standards are recognized as a scientific benchmark worldwide. The European Pharmacopoeia is legally binding in all member states. The activities elaborating quality monographs of Traditional Chinese Medicines for the European consumers/ patients started in 2005 following a decision of the Ph Eur Commission, which stated that monographs on herbal drugs used in Traditional Chinese Medicine should be developed to provide modern quality standards according to the pre-existing Ph Eur standards. Following this decision in 2005, the existing groups of experts 13A and B (Phytochemistry) received a note from the Ph Eur Commission Secretariat to include in their working program Chinese Medicines products listed as monographs in the ChP 2005. It was then stated that the elaboration of monographs on TCM herbals should provide modern quality standards according to the Ph Eur principles which should facilitate and encourage the use by the practitioners and further to provide save and authorized products to the patient.

From legal perspective, the Directive (Directive 2004/24/ EC) on Traditional Herbal Medicine Products existing in the European Medicine Agency (EMA) should be the basis for simplified registration procedures[6] from that time onward, based on traditional use and ensuring quality and safety without the need to prove efficacy by clinical studies of the product. Therefore, elaboration of Ph Eur monographs for TCM is fundamentally important for all quality parameters for the TCM product intended to stay/entering the EU market.

Priority setting of TCM herbal drug candidates was proposed according to a number of documented criteria such as toxicity, risk of substitution, adulterations, volume of use etc. A coordination with the work program of the Committee on Herbal Traditional Products (HMP) of the EMA and the existence of a monograph on a related herbal drug in the actual Chinese Pharmacopeia (ChP) was an essential prerequisite. It was also decided that herbal drug preparations and compounded products should not be dealt with for the time being.

A priority setting of individual monograph candidates by both groups 13A and B (expert groups working for European herbal medicine monographs at EDQM) followed the criteria such as order of overall importance in the EU, quality and completeness of an existing monograph in ChP, and the extent of use in the respective EU Member States and finally, the availability of herbal drug samples on the European and on the International Market.

Initially, more than 100 TCM herbal drug candidates were proposed and out of these, about 75 TCM herbal drugs were finally selected and put in the initial Working Program. First start was made with an evaluation of existing ChP monographs followed by an experimental reexamination of the methods, in order to fulfill the guidelines of the Ph Eur.

With regard to these TCM herbal drugs the ChP Monographs could serve as a basis for the Ph Eur Monographs. However, a number of issues had to be addressed since all Ph Eur monographs have to take into account the relevant style and quality parameters currently required for all Monographs of the Ph Eur.

  Establishment of the TCM Working Party by the Ph Eur Commission (EDQM) Top

After an initial phase of about two years, the Group of Experts 13A and 13B (European Scientists working at EDQM for European herbal drugs) had to stop the activities in elaborating Monographs on Traditional Chinese Medicine Herbals. This was based on the annual reporting of the Working Program to the European Pharmacopoeia Commission at EDQM, it was found that Groups 13A and 13B had only the capacity to work on European Herbal Drugs. This fact was the basis for the creation of a Working Party on Traditional Chinese Medicine in 2008 by the Ph Eur Commission at the EDQM.

Therefore, specialists from all EU Member States were needed and the profile for experts and specialists was then summarized by the European Pharmacopoeia Commission. Consequently the experts/specialists should have:

  • Current expertise in pharmaceutical and analytical methods related to quality control of Herbal Drugs and Herbal Drug Preparations and in development of control methods.
  • Access to laboratory facilities for verification of methods proposed for inclusion of Monographs.
  • Several years of experience in one or more of the following fields:

  • - quality control of Herbal Drugs and Herbal Drug Preparation

    - involvement in market surveillance or regulatory affairs oversight of imported TCM Herbal Drugs

    - knowledge of cultivation, harvesting, conservation

    - development of chromatographic separations systems for Herbal Drug constituents

    - knowledge of use of TCM Herbal Drugs

According to these profile for experts and specialists, the different National Authorities were asked to propose candidates which were then nominated by the Ph Eur Commission in the November 2007 Session. Nomination of experts and specialists based on the proposals made by the National Authorities of the EU Member States is carried out by the Presidium of the Ph Eur Commission. Then the Commission nominates the Chairman for the Working Party. The next step was the definition of the Working Program for the newly established TCM Working Party. It is important to note that only the Ph Eur Commission has the right to approve or remove items of the Working Program or to approve requests for revisions.

In 2008, the official TCM working party with 18 scientists with relevant scientific background as members plus the Chairman of the Working Party was established at EDQM. The members are officially elected by the delegations of the European Member States with approval of Ph Eur commission [Table 1]. Since then, the scientific team has been working on elaboration of TCM herbal drug monographs for Ph Eur.
Table 1: Members of TCM working party at EDQM

Click here to view

According to the rules of procedure, the progress on the Working Program is reviewed once a year by the Ph Eur Commission, usually in the March Session, where chairs have to report regularly to the Commission about progress of the Working Program, highlighting items and work that did not fulfill the expected results with explanation of reasons. The Chairman, with the support from the Secretariat at EDQM, is responsible for the progress of the work allocated to each Group of Experts or Working Party. In consultation with the members in the Group of Experts or Working Party, the Chairman establishes the working plan, and the distribution of the work, in concern of the targets, to ensure that the target deadlines are respected.

  Procedure For Elaboration of Ph Eur Monographs Top

It should always be kept in mind that a Monograph from any TCM herbal drug should be drafted with the same overall structure as other European Pharmacopoeia Monographs, based on the latest version of the Technical Guide for the Elaboration of Monographs and on the Style Guide. It has to be recalled that all tests and assay methods described in a Monograph must be validated according to the procedures dated in the Technical Guide. All the details of the general Monograph on Herbal Drugs and Herbal Drug Preparations must be taken into consideration for the elaboration of the individual TCM Herbal Drug Monographs.

The general procedures for establishment of a monograph at Ph Eur are outlined in [Figure 1]A which is different from Ch P procedure [Figure 1]B. The Ph Eur Commission decides to elaborate or revise a monograph, followed by the WP to appoint a rapporteur for this specific monograph. The appointed rapporteur will be responsible to prepare a draft monograph based on scientific research and evaluation. Then this draft monograph will be published in Pharmeuropa, an official journal of the Ph Eur. The draft monograph is for public inquiry and National Pharmacopeia Authorities process the comments to the published draft monograph. The WP examines the comments and revises the draft monograph accordingly. Then the revised draft monograph is proposed to Ph Eur Commissions for adoption (named COM document). With the approval of the Ph Eur commission the monograph will be published and becomes an official Ph Eur Monograph [Figure 1]A. The above mentioned procedure will usually take about two years to complete an official monograph.

Click here to view

  Working Program of the TCM Working Party Top

As the Ph Eur Commission has stated that “monographs on herbal drugs used in Traditional Chinese Medicine should be developed to give a modern quality standard according to European Pharmacopeia principle and to facilitate the encourage use by practitioners for safe, authorized products”, therefore the tasks of TCM WP are development of TCM drug monographs that are frequently used in European market. Herbal drugs used in Traditional Chinese Medicine are found in several forms on the European market:

  • Crude herbal drugs which have not been submitted to any treatment other than physical treatment such as cleaning, fragmentation and drying.
  • Prepared (processed) herbal drugs which have been subjected to one or more treatments such as exposure to dry heat, boiling, cooking in various solutions etc.
  • Herbal drugs occurring in a crude and processed form
  • Preparations derived from herbal drugs which comprised crude or processed drugs that have been involved in a processing method which necessarily includes other ingredients, such as vinegar, honey, ginger or other excipients.

At present, the TCM Working Party of the Ph Eur Commission is only working on single TCM herbal drugs in a crude and/or processed form. The preparation of the TCM herbal drug monograph in the Ph Eur must always be according to the Ph Eur Style and Technic Guidelines, using ChP (editions 2005 and 2010) as basis but taking into consideration the information from the WHO monographs on selected medicinal plants, and the Hong Kong Chinese Materia Medica Standard (HKCMMS) as well. Some comparisons between Ph Eur and Ch P was made previously[7]. In general a monograph of the actual Ph Eur 8th edition consists of the following chapters: Definition, Identification, Test, and Assay. There is a significant difference in structural organization of all the monographs (see [Figure 2]) between Ph Eur and Ch P, some information implemented in the ChP are not present in the Ph Eur. Examples of these are the herbal drugs prepared as slices, processing methods, therapeutic property, flavor and taste, meridian tropism, actions, indications, precaution, administrations and dosages. This is because the Ph Eur only deals with quality related matters and not with herbal drug indications and administration of these. In the chapter Definition, the complete scientific name of the plant (including genus, species, subspecies, variety and author) is presented in Ph Eur. As an example, the major difference in the chapter Definition of a monograph between Ph Eur and Ch P is presented in [Figure 3] using the newly published monograph Polygoni multiflori radix. In general, the Ph Eur will present the state of the drug such as if it is whole, fragmented, peeled, fresh or dried. Wherever possible, the minimum content of quantified constituents is specified by Ph Eur. The major difference is that there is no information on the systematic name of the respective plant family, collection period and Chinese title, while the Latin name used for this herbal drug including the new systematic name and possible synonyms of Polygoni multiflori radix and minimum content of quality related marker compounds are always provided in the Ph Eur [Figure 3]. According to the principles of Ph Eur, the identification of a herbal drug should be relatively simple and be possible to be carried out by e.g. community pharmacies with in general the combination of different methods that allow the identification of a herbal drug without the use of expensive equipment. Both, Ph Eur and Ch P have in common that they present finger printing (TLC and/or HPTLC) and microscopic botanical characteristics. In Ph Eur, a drawing of a microscopy study of the powdered herbal drug and a box type table of results from TLC/HPTLC are presented. However, there is no description of the herbal drug prepared ready for decoction also named “sliced drug” in Ph Eur. Therefore there is also no microscopy study for this type of “sliced drug” in Ph Eur. Within quality related issues, there is a large similarity in scientific information between Ph Eur and Ch P [Figure 2]. For Ph Eur, wherever possible, an assay has to be included to determine the constituents based on scientific data supporting therapeutic activity, such as an active therapeutic maker or analytic marker compound.

Click here to view
Figure 3: Parameters related to quality control in Chapter of Test in Ph Eur.

Click here to view

Markers are chemically defined constituents or groups of constituents which are of interest for control purpose independent of whether they have any therapeutic activity. Markers serve to calculate the quantity of herbal substance(s) or herbal preparation (s) in the Herbal Medicinal Product if that marker has been quantitatively determined in the herbal substance(s) or herbal preparation(s) themselves. There are two categories of markers: 1). Active markers: are constituents or groups of constituents which are generally accepted to contribute the therapeutic activity (with scientific data support); 2). Analytical markers: are constituents or groups of constituents that serve for analytical purposes. Both type of markers are used in Ph Eur assays. The method used for determination of the specific constituent is preferably by LC or GC with a corresponding reference standard Chemical Reference Standard (CRS) or Herbal Reference Standard (HRS) that is established by EDQM. The decision on the choice of the compound as marker should be scientifically justified but also be sustainable for practical purpose in pharmacies. When a marker is used in a monograph of a herbal drug in Ch P (edition 2005 or 2010), in principle, the same marker is used in Ph Eur, except when the assay for this marker is not sustainable or there is already an alternative marker developed in Ph Eur. The analytical results obtained may be presented differently in Ph Eur as compared to Ch P, as is, for example, the case with HPLC assays.

In the Ph Eur chapter Test various quality control related parameters are presented in [Figure 4]. The measurements of contaminates such as heavy metals and mycotoxins are not included in the monograph of ChP (ChP. 2005 and 2010). Whilst Ph Eur has clearly stated the methods for measuring aflatoxin B and ochratoxin A in herbal drugs and provides limits for heavy metals (e.g. for lead the maximum is 5.0 ppm; for mercury the maximum is 0.1 ppm and for cadmium the maximum is 1.0 ppm). A more detailed description of Ph Eur’s work was reported previously[7].
Figure 4: The role of Ph Eur TCM monograph in Europe Ph Eur.

Click here to view

Up to present, 43 TCM herbal drugs are adopted in Ph Eur 8th edition including supplements 8.1–8.4 (see [Table 2]) of which 34 monographs are the results of the TCM working party at EDQM. Two monographs (Lycii fructus (2612) and Angelica dahurica root (2556)) were adopted by the Ph Eur Commission and two more monographs (Anemarrhenae rhizoma (2661) and Persicariae tinctoriae folium (2727)) were submitted to the Ph Eur Commission. There are 21 monographs published in the official journal of Ph Eur, Pharmeuropa [Table 3].
Table 2: Monographs of Chinese Herbs Adopted in the European Pharmacopeia (Ph Eur)

Click here to view
Table 3: Monographs of Chinese Herbs Published in Pharmeuropa Editions 26.3, 26.4 and 27.1

Click here to view

  Inclusion of Pinyin Names and Sinograms in the Title of Monographs Top

The English Title of a Monograph consists of the botanical scientific name of the plant which is often a translation of the Latin Title. The plant part used may be included in the title, particularly where different Herbal Drugs are derived from the same plant. In this case it is specified after the scientific name of the plant.

One problem, which partly is resolved by the TCM WP is the introduction of the Chinese Pinyin name as well as the Sinograms for Traditional Chinese Herbal Drugs into the Monographs of the Ph Eur, so that the specialists exactly know what kind of herbs they are dealing with. Reintroducing Chinese Pinyin names will highlight to which therapeutic system the given herbal drug belongs. Most European TCM practitioners always use Pinyin names of these herbal drugs when writing a prescription, and consequently the pharmacists throughout Europe should be encouraged to become familiar with these Pinyin names. When the original names are being removed from the title of the Monograph, this will have an opposite effect. Having the Pinyin names in the Monographs Title will facilitate the work of the Pharmacist and there is no need for any additional reference manuals beside the European Pharmacopoeia. Since some herbal drugs originate from many continents (e. g. Europe and China) the Pinyin name will clearly differentiate between these herbs. For example for Angelica sp. where several species are appearing in Europe and China they can easily be differentiated by the Pinyin names.

The argument, that using the Chinese name for TCM Herbal Drugs will lead to misidentification does not hold. Chinese names will never replace the Latin names in the Monograph. They do supply additional information important for exact identification of different herbs of the same genus. Pinyin names thus provide reliable criteria for differentiation in any occasion of doubt. Due to all these reasons it was decided that Pinyin names and Sinograms should appear somewhere in the Ph Eur. The final decision was, that a special chapter should be established, where the TCM Herbal Drugs are being listed with the English-, Latin, French and Pinyin name plus Sinogram. This chapter has been recently published (Pharmaeuropa 26.4, also see [Table 2]) and will be complemented by any addition of a new TCM Herbal Drug which has been accepted by the Commission ready for publication in Ph Eur.

  Scientific Challenge For Bridging Ph Eur and CH P: Top

Processing of TCM material medica

The materia medica of TCM mainly consists of herbal products such as dried roots, rhizomes, stems, leaves, flowers, fruits and seeds. The major application form in Traditional Chinese Pharmacotherapy is a decoction. Due to the sometimes very voluminous herbal drugs, total drugs are not suitable as raw material for decoctions; they should be processed before usage. The processing of medicinal plant materials has a history as long as Traditional Chinese Medicine itself, The first complete guidebook of herbal preparation goes back to the year 470. The importance of the processing of materials has already been mentioned in the Huang Di Nei Jing (The Yellow Emperor’s Internal Classic, 475-221 B.C.) and Shen Nong Ben Cao Jing (Divine Husbandman’s Classic of the Materia Medica, c. 220 A.D.)[8] Depending on the therapeutic application, the same plant material can be processed differently. In current TCM practice, all the materials are strictly required to be properly processed before using for therapeutic application. Most TCM herbal drugs are in processed form and the purposes of processing are highlighted[9]:

  • Achieving drugs of consistent quality and amount for constant and better effectiveness, better storability.
  • Reducing toxic effects or undesired side effects.
  • Modifying the effect of the herb by traditional, empiric methods.
  • Increasing the effect of the herb by traditional, empiric methods
  • Modifying molecular structure of the material used to increase solubility.
  • Removing unpleasant smells.
  • Preparing drug material with completely different therapeutic property as compared with raw the materials.

Understanding the metabolic changes during processing is of great important for quality control of Chinese medicinal herbal materials. Some intensive studies have been done on the processing of e. g. Rehmannia glutinosa roots[10],[11]. In those studies, the role of processing was to modify the therapeutic properties of the herbal drug Rehmannia glutinosa roots that was associated with changes of metabolic profiling during the processing. Effect of processing for reduction of toxicity is another issue for TCM herbal drugs, herewith an example of Aconiti radix is given: this refers to the root part of the medicinal plant that belongs to the genus of the family Ranunculaceae and is comprised of about 400 species of which 166 are endemic in China (http://www. efloras.org/flora_page.aspx?flora_id=2). The most well-known species is Aconitum napellus (Monk’s hood wolfs-bane, aconite). Among them, only two species are used in TCM; Aconitum carmichaeli Debx and Aconitum kusnezoffi Reichb. The herbal medicines in the Ch P are Radix Aconitum carmichaeli (Chuanwu, from the major root of the species Aconitum carmichaeli Debx.) and its processed form Radix Aconitum Preparata (Zhichuanwu), Radix Aconitum Kusnezoffii (Caowu, from the root of Aconitum Kusnezoffii Reichb), and its processed form Radix Aconitum Kusnezoffii Preparata (Zhicaowu), Folium Aconitum Kusne- zoffii (Caowuye) and the processed Radix Aconitum Lateralis Preparata (Fuzi, the lateral root of the species Aconitum carmichaeli Debx.)[9]. In the early ShengNong BenCao Jing, Radix Aconitum carmichaeli (Chuanwu) was already recorded as a high risk medicine. Diterpene alkaloids are major chemical components of Radix Aconitum carmichaeli. Aconitum roots, and some findings[12] demonstrated that proper processing and multi-herbs formulation can reduce the level of toxic components. This also explains that in TCM, some herbal drugs, such as Aconitum and Ephedra species are never used as single herb for intervention and that aconite is only used when it is processed and in combination with specific matched other herbs. Although some reports about the metabolite changes during processing can be identified in the literature, yet, many processed TCM drugs still require scientific studies.

During processing, not only the metabolites changes are important for quality control, but, various methods are used for processing in TCM as well. Although there is a significant difference between regions in China, in general processing can be classified into 17 different categories[13] (see [Table 5].). Under each category there are still different variations and in most case there are no scientific parameters defined to the described categories. Moreover, for the processing, various excipients are used. In [Table 6] at least 10 different type of excipients used in TCM processing are shown[13]. The excipients used in TCM herbal drug processing are quite diverse and without scientific parameters for quality descriptions as well.
Table 5: Seventeen ancient processing methods (Zhang and Cai 1984)

Click here to view
Table 6: Ten different type of excipients used in processing (Zhang and Cai 1984)

Click here to view

The most important tasks from the TCM working Party of the Ph Eur will be a joint cooperation between scientists in the field to develop qualitative and quantitative parameters for TCM drug processing procedures, standard operation protocols (SOP) and defined quality parameters for all excipients used in these procedures.

  Cooperation Between Scientists in Europe and China Top

Since 2011 the Chinese State Administration of TCM (SATCM) has established a formal cooperation between EDQM, An agreement between both parties was signed in June 2011. The purpose of this cooperation is to promote the cooperation between SATCM of the People’s Republic of China and the European Council represented by the EDQM. A mutual cooperation of both parties was established aiming to prepare the quality standards concerning a series of TCM herbal drugs - herbal drug extracts. Both Parties intend to speed up the establishment of high quality standards of TCM in Europe in order to ensure the safety and quality of TCM for the patients.

With the support of Mr. Daning Li from SATCM (former vice director of SATCM), a National Key Laboratory for TCM (NKL-TCM) was established from China side. Scientists in China have joint in the preparation of TCM drug monographs in the TCM working party of EDQM. Chinese scientists supported the following aspects: provide scientific literatures originated from Chinese modern and ancients documents (translating from Chinese language to English language), answer the questions related to TCM drug processing, provide TCM drugs samples, participate in the preparation of TCM monographs by conducting scientific experimental works such as TLC and HPLC studies and development of new quality markers for TCM herbal drugs. From China side, a leading scientist in the field is visiting TCM WP meeting on a regular basis, so that the interactions between scientists from China and Europe are strengthened considerably. Recently, SATCM also suggested new 15 herbal drugs to be added to the Ph Eur TCM WP Working Program (see [Table 4]).
Table 4: New Chinese Herbs Working List Proposed by SATCM

Click here to view

  Role of TCM Herbal Drug Monographs in Europe Top

TCM herbal drug monographs play an important role in quality control for TCM practitioners who are prescribing TCM herbal drugs for their patients/consumers. The present situation in Europe is that the average European TCM practitioner is using 300 TCM drugs in his/her daily practice and the commercial importers provides up to 400 TCM drugs. In European Chinese medicine clinics, there are around 500 TCM drugs being used. The number of quality monographs at this moment is still very limited and cannot serve the needs to EU consumers. To meet the demands of the consumers, much more quality monographs are needed.

Basically there are two types of monographs related to herbal medicine/drugs in Europe. One of them are the EDQM’s European Pharmacopeia monographs, which are dealing with quality aspects of the herbal medicine/drugs only. The other type of monograph, named “Community Herbal monographs”, is prepared by the European Medicines Agency (EMA) and is dealing with safety and efficiency of herbal medicine/drugs. As both types of monograph play in concert to contribute to the regulation of herbal medicines/ drugs in safe use of TCM drugs for consumers in Europe [Figure 2], it is important to have frequently used TCM drugs in the EU to be regulated by both, quality and safety/ efficiency rules. Up to now, there are only 10 EMA “Community herbal monographs” for TCM products[14], and already 43 TCM herbal drug monographs adopted by the Ph Eur. The present article mainly focused on EDQM’s herbal drug monographs, which will be the key for a quality standard for herbal drugs used in Europe. This quality standard can be applied to herbal raw materials that are

  Outlook for the Future Development of TCM Products in Europe Top

The classical therapeutic dosage form in TCM therapy is the hot water decoction of mostly a complex mixture of different TCM herbal drugs. In order to facilitate the compliance of these aqueous extracts, large scale decoctions at an industrial level are spray dried, mixed with excipients and formulated to the so called granules, which have recently been introduced in large amounts to the European market. The necessary quality parameters, however, of these TCM products is often not provided and sometimes rather doubtful, since the preparation methods for these solid forms of decoctions are not officially specified and hence, there are often considerable differences in the overall composition when comparing a classical decoction versus any granule preparation of the commerce.

A very promising step forward for the general acceptance of TCM products in the European Countries should be the industrial production of defined and specified extracts from single TCM herbs or even from complex mixtures of several herbal drugs. These, by Ph Eur monographs qualified extracts are the common basis for any legal registration by either the respective National Authorities or even by the EMA in London for all the European Member States. A first positive example in this direction was the production and registration of a defined saponin extract obtained from the TCM herbal drug Dioscorea nipponica rhizome, which now is the basis for the newly registered Phytomedicine DXXK in the Netherlands[15].

Consequently, the Ph Eur Commission inaugurated the elaboration of the respective quality monograph for this herbal drug (Dioscorea nipponica rhizome) to be implemented in the Ph Eur. The following step should be, to elaborate the corresponding quality monograph of the Dioscorea nipponica rhizome extract, and further to classify this new extract as a standardised-, quantified- or other extract according to the rules of the Ph Eur Monograph on Herbal Extracts. This adoption of a first TCM herbal drug as the basis of a registered European phytomedicine (DXXK) should be an important signal for the Pharmaceutical Industry in China, to follow a similar way, i.e., to produce defined herbal extracts with well-established pharmacological and clinical data as the basis for any registration in either individual countries of the EU or for all EU Member States by the centralised registration procedure via the EMA in London[16].

Following the future initiatives of the Chinese Pharmaceutical Industry, the Ph Eur will react accordingly by elaborating the respective Quality Monographs for both, the TCM herbal drug and the respective defined extract following the rules and guidelines specified for herbal drugs and herbal drug preparations (extracts). It can be hoped that in the near future intensified contacts and collaborations between Chinese and European Officials and between Chinese and European Pharmaceutical Industries can be inaugurated in order to create most efficient new TCM phytomedicines for the patients in Europe.

  References Top

Hua-Ching N. I Ching: The book of changes and the unchanging truth, 2nd edition. SevenStar Communications; 1999.  Back to cited text no. 1
Van der Greef J, Van Wietmarschen H, Schroën J, Wang M, Hankemeier T, Xu G. Systems Biology-Based Diagnostic Principles as Pillars of the Bridge between Chinese and Western Medicine Plant Med 2010, 76: 2036-2047.  Back to cited text no. 2
Wang M, Lamers R-J, Korthout HAAJ, Nesselrooij JHJ, Witkamp RF, Verpoorte R, van der Greef J. Metabolomics in the context of systems biology: Bridging traditional Chinese medicine and molecular pharmacology. J. Phytother Res 2005, Mar; 19(3): 173-82.  Back to cited text no. 3
Chen FP, Chen TJ, Kung YY, Chen YC, Chou LF, Chen FJ, Hwang SJ. Use frequency of traditional Chinese medicine in Taiwan. BMC Health Services Research 2007, 7: 26-36.  Back to cited text no. 4
Hosbach I, Neeb G, Hager S, Kirchhoff S, Kirschbaum B. In defence of traditional Chinese herbal medicine. Anaesthesia 2003, 58: 282-283.  Back to cited text no. 5
Barbara Steinhoff. The first HMPC community herbal monographs. Phytomedicine 2006, 13: 378-379.  Back to cited text no. 6
Bauer R and Franz G. Modern European Monographs for Quality control of Chinese herbs. Planta medica 2010, 76: 2004-2011.  Back to cited text no. 7
Chang HC, Tsay QH. “Processing of Chinese Medicine Materials (Second edition),” China Medical College Press, Taichung, 2003, pp. 2-4.  Back to cited text no. 8
Zhu YP. “Chinese Materia Medica, Chemistry, Pharmacology and Applications,” Taylor & Francis, London, 1998, pp. 17-23.  Back to cited text no. 9
Chang WT, Thissen U, Ehlert KA, Koek MM, Jellema RJ, Hankemeier T, Van der Greef J, Wang M. Effects of Growth Conditions and Processing on Rehmannia glutinosa L. Using Fingerprint Strategy. Planta Medica 2006, 72(5): 458-467.  Back to cited text no. 10
Chang WT, Young Hae HC, van der Heijden R, Lee MS, Lin MK, Kong H, Kim KK, R. Verpoorte, Hankemeier T, van der Greef J, Wang M. Traditional Processing Strongly Affects Metabolite Composition by Hydrolysis in Rehmannia glutinosa Roots Chem. Pharm. Bull 2010, 59(5): 546 -552.  Back to cited text no. 11
Wang J, Reijmers T, Chen L, Van der Hoeve R, Wang M, Peng S, Hankemeier T, Zu G, Van der Greef J. Systems toxiology study of doxorubicin on rats using ultra performance liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry based metabolomics. Metabolomics 2009, 5(4).  Back to cited text no. 12
Zhang XC, Cai GH. Processing of TCM. Beijing: China medicine science, 1984.  Back to cited text no. 13
Qu L, Zou W, Zhou Z, Zhang T, van der Greef J and Wang M. Non- European traditional herbal medicines in Europe: a Community herbal monograph perspective. 2014 Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 156: 107-114.  Back to cited text no. 14
Dutch Medicines Evaluation Board, 2012a. First Authorisation of Traditional Herbal Medicine from outside the European Union. Available from URL: http://www.cbg-meb.nl/CBG/en/human-medicines/ actueel/First_Authorisation_of_Traditional_Herbal_Medicine_from_out side_the_European_Union/default.htm. Accessed on March 22, 2012.  Back to cited text no. 15
Committee on herbal medicinal products, 2005a. Guideline on the assessment of clinical safety and efficacy in the preparation of community herbal monographs for well-established and of community herbal monographs/entries to the community list for traditional herbal medicinal products/substances/preparations. Available from URL: http:// www.ema.europa.eu/docs/en_GB/document_library/Scientific_guide line/2009/09/WC500003644.pdf. Accessed on September 7, 2006.  Back to cited text no. 16


  [Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4]

  [Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6]

This article has been cited by
1 Rapid Determination of Lignans in Schisandra chinensis by Supramolecular Solvent (SUPRAS)-Based Extraction and High-Performance Liquid Chromatography–Tandem Mass Spectrometry (HPLC-MS)
Lina Fu, Litao Wang, Su Zhang, Yujie Fu
Analytical Letters. 2023; : 1
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
2 Efficacy and safety of traditional Chinese medicine for cancer-related fatigue: a systematic literature review of randomized controlled trials
Jingya Yang, Yuxiao Li, Chi Ian Chau, Junnan Shi, Xianwen Chen, Hao Hu, Carolina Oi Lam Ung
Chinese Medicine. 2023; 18(1)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
3 Ma’s bamboo-based medicinal moxibustion therapy of low back pain in lumbar disc herniation: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial
Xian-zhu Wang, Kai-yang Xue, Ping-nan Chen, Cai-hong Xiao, Jin Cui, Jing Fu
Trials. 2022; 23(1)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
4 Effects of Acupuncture-Related Therapies in the Rehabilitation of Patients with Post-Stroke Aphasia—A Network Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Pengpeng Liang, Yufei Li, Yanan Feng, Guoliang Yin, Suwen Chen, Xiangyi Liu, Fengxia Zhang
Brain Sciences. 2022; 12(10): 1282
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
5 Market access for Chinese herbal medicinal products in Europe—A ten-year review of relevant products, policies, and challenges
Yin Xiong, Minghui Li, Pengyue Sun, Wen Liang, Ryan G. Hornbeck, Xiaoyan Che, Cheng Rao, Ye Zhao, Liqun Guo, Yan Huang, Hua Yang, Ping Li, Burt H. Kroes, Xiuming Cui, Gerhard Franz, Mei Wang
Phytomedicine. 2022; 103: 154237
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
6 Key quality factors for Chinese herbal medicines entering the EU market
Mei Wang, Pei-Fen Yao, Peng-Yue Sun, Wen Liang, Xiao-Jia Chen
Chinese Medicine. 2022; 17(1)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
7 The internationalization of TCM towards Portuguese-speaking countries
Xiaoting Zheng,Liyang Lyu,Hong Lu,Yuanjia Hu,Ging Chan
Chinese Medicine. 2021; 16(1)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
8 Analysis of historical changes in traditional Chinese medicine based on an Indonesian collection of Chinese materia medica from c. 1870
Yusheng Jia,Lei Lei,Xiao Luo,Zhongzhen Zhao,Mei Wang,Tinde van Andel
Journal of Ethnopharmacology. 2021; 269: 113714
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
9 Clinical research of postpartum pantalgia treated with individualized moxibustion ????????????????
Wan-yu ZHANG,Ying DING,Bai-pu XU
World Journal of Acupuncture - Moxibustion. 2021;
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
10 Potential Effects of Nutraceuticals in Retinopathy of Prematurity
Jessica K. W. Tsang,Susanne A. Wolf,Inga M. Pompoes,Antonia M. Joussen,Wai Ching Lam,Di Yang,Amy C. Y. Lo
Life. 2021; 11(2): 79
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
11 Estimation of total tannin and total phenolic content in plant (Crataegus azarolus L) by orbital shaker technique
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Food Sciences. 2021; : 1
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
12 Medicinal Plant Analysis: A Historical and Regional Discussion of Emergent Complex Techniques
Martin Fitzgerald,Michael Heinrich,Anthony Booker
Frontiers in Pharmacology. 2020; 10
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
13 Ultra-high performance liquid chromatography/ion mobility-quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry and database-driven automatic peak annotation for the rapid profiling and characterization of the multicomponents from Stephaniae Tetrandrae radix (Fang-Ji)
Yue-Xin Qian,Hu-Min Xie,Tian-Tian Zuo,Xue Li,Ying Hu,Hong-Da Wang,Xiu-Mei Gao,Wen-Zhi Yang
World Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2020; 0(0): 0
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
14 Integrated assessment of medicinal rhubarb by combination of delayed luminescence and HPLC fingerprint with emphasized on bioactivities based quality control
Mengmeng Sun,Hongwei Wu,Min He,Yusheng Jia,Lixue Wang,Ting Liu,Lianqiang Hui,Li Li,Shengli Wei,Eduard Van Wijk,Roeland Van Wijk,Karl Wah-Keung Tsim,Chun Li,Mei Wang
Chinese Medicine. 2020; 15(1)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
15 Quality standard of traditional Chinese medicines: comparison between European Pharmacopoeia and Chinese Pharmacopoeia and recent advances
Fong Leong,Xue Hua,Mei Wang,Tongkai Chen,Yuelin Song,Pengfei Tu,Xiao-Jia Chen
Chinese Medicine. 2020; 15(1)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
16 The Application of Traditional Chinese Medicine Injection on Patients with Acute Coronary Syndrome during the Perioperative Period of Percutaneous Coronary Intervention: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Zhaofeng Shi,Chen Zhao,Jiayuan Hu,Qianqian Dai,Manke Guan,Changming Zhong,Guihua Tian,Hongcai Shang
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2020; 2020: 1
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
17 Application of delayed luminescence measurements for the identification of herbal materials: a step toward rapid quality control
Mengmeng Sun,Shengpeng Wang,Yong Jing,Li Li,Min He,Yusheng Jia,Eduard van Wijk,Yitao Wang,Zhihong Wang,Mei Wang
Chinese Medicine. 2019; 14(1)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
18 Characterization of ginsenoside extracts by delayed luminescence, high-performance liquid chromatography, and bioactivity tests
Mengmeng Sun,Min He,Henrie Korthout,Mahmoud Halima,Hye Kyong Kim,Yu Yan,Eduard van Wijk,Roeland van Wijk,Chunsheng Guo,Mei Wang
Photochemical & Photobiological Sciences. 2019; 18(5): 1138
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
19 Novel approach to combat antibiotic resistance: evaluation of some Armenian herb crude extracts for their antibiotic modulatory and antiviral properties
M. Ginovyan,A. Trchounian
Journal of Applied Microbiology. 2019; 127(2): 472
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
20 Rapid Simultaneous Determination of Andrographolides in Andrographis paniculata by Near-Infrared Spectroscopy
Xiudi Lai,Junni Li,Xue Gong,Xiaojing Lin,Gengqiu Tang,Rong Li,Canchao Jia,Dong Wang,Shengguo Ji
Analytical Letters. 2018; 51(17): 2747
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
21 SWOT analysis and revelation in traditional Chinese medicine internationalization
Haitao Tang,Wenlong Huang,Jimei Ma,Li Liu
Chinese Medicine. 2018; 13(1)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
22 Characterization of the therapeutic properties of Chinese herbal materials by measuring delayed luminescence and dendritic cell-based immunomodulatory response
Mengmeng Sun,Wen-Te Chang,Eduard Van Wijk,Min He,Slavik Koval,Ming-Kuem Lin,Roel Van Wijk,Thomas Hankemeier,Jan van der Greef,Mei Wang
Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology B: Biology. 2017; 168: 1
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
23 Experimental Paper. Intrapopulation variability of flavonoid content in roots of Baikal skullcap (Scutellaria baicalensis Georgi)
Olga Kosakowska
Herba Polonica. 2017; 63(1): 20
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
24 Chemical variability of common skullcap (Scutellaria galericulata L.) wild growing in the area of eastern Poland
Olga Kosakowska,Katarzyna Baczek,Jaroslaw L. Przybyl,Ewelina Pióro-Jabrucka,Zenon Weglarz
Herba Polonica. 2016; 62(3): 7
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
25 Barriers and countermeasures in developing traditional Chinese medicine in Europe
Yunfang Liu,Zhiping Yang,Jing Cheng,Daiming Fan
Frontiers of Medicine. 2016; 10(3): 360
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
26 Residues and contaminants in medicinal herbs—A review
Vandana Tripathy,B.B. Basak,Thania Sara Varghese,Ajoy Saha
Phytochemistry Letters. 2015; 14: 67
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
27 Phlegm-Dampness Constitution: Genomics, Susceptibility, Adjustment and Treatment with Traditional Chinese Medicine
Ji Wang,Qi Wang,Lingru Li,Yingshuai Li,Huimin Zhang,Luyu Zheng,Lingling Yang,Yanfei Zheng,Yin Yang,Guiying Peng,Yan Zhang,Yuanyuan Han
The American Journal of Chinese Medicine. 2013; 41(02): 253
[Pubmed] | [DOI]


    Similar in PUBMED
   Search Pubmed for
   Search in Google Scholar for
 Related articles
    Access Statistics
    Email Alert *
    Add to My List *
* Registration required (free)  

  In this article
Establishment of...
Procedure For El...
Working Program ...
Inclusion of Pin...
Scientific Chall...
Cooperation Betw...
Role of TCM Herb...
Outlook for the ...
Article Figures
Article Tables

 Article Access Statistics
    PDF Downloaded93    
    Comments [Add]    
    Cited by others 27    

Recommend this journal